> Your rant about big bloated GNOME is... well just a rant. You will
They already are - its dying slowly but surely.
Interesting how you associate ease of use with being bloated and oversize.
Ah of course. How sweet, your response to a point about the arrogance of
certain desktop attitudes is to lecture, and make bogus pronouncements
about command-line people. You might want to put the shovel away instead.
And a bit of pop psychology to go with it. I assume you are trying to
talk about internalised and externalised models ?
No of course not we are all dim, thank you for using small words. I am
actually familiar with the real models here btw and there are a couple of
rather important basics you are missing
- Different people have different strengths in different areas - these
don't specifically line up with the senses. There isn't vast amounts of
evidence to support computing people are all strong in a particular
area either. You'll see in studies that some of them prefer to
diagram and flowchart, some write text, some have kinesthetic models
(movement and flow). I don't doubt there are others who sense it in
different ways.
- Visual and textual data communicate different things more effectively
(as do sounds, smells, movements, ....) and are processed with
different natural preferences by different people
- Oh and there is no evidence I've ever seen to suggest old people are
more text oriented.
So any notion of CLI's or GUI's being better for [class of people] is
generally naïve. It depends what is being done, who is doing it and the
situation.
If you really want to understand the trade-offs in a graphical world
watch some good CAD operators for an hour. They'll use the same tools in
very different ways - some very command line, some heavily
mouse/trackball, others graphical but with hotkeys, and they'll often
shift approach according to task.
If you wish to see an unadapted person you probably want to go look at
amazonian tribes. Bit different.
But then the GUI world is the world that put "logout" under "start" 8)
and thinks that "Insert OLE Object" is a good thing to put on a menu.
Alan
--
