On Jan 22, 2008 12:02 PM, Kevin Ballard <kevin@sb.org> wrote:
quoted text
> I'd imagine writing an OS to be a horrifically complicated task. And yes, I
> can certainly imagine HFS+ might have issues when used to back an NFS server
> with other clients, but that still leads back to the original point, which
> is that all these problems stem from the differences between HFS+ and other
> filesystems, not any inherent problem with HFS+ itself.

Right. If you are defining the requirements for a new FS on a new OS,
would you not include a requirement that says "must not add any funny
rule that prevents clean interoperation with other filesystems or
OSs"? Forgetting that requirement is... a big one! And if someone asks
"how do we do nice user-friendly filename matching with these
technical differences that users mostly don't care about"... wouldn't
you say "do it in the GUI facilities, changing the FS to handle this
is wrong because it will break the OS as a server, as a reliable file
storage"?

FSs have pretty hard requirements these days -- all the modern FS
you've heard about respect the requirement above, and a ton more that
you have to be in the FS business to be aware of. Mostly anyway,
wherever they don't, users have all sorts of trouble.

quoted text
> IIRC, the biggest problem he talked about was the changing unicode standard,
> but since the technote appears to state that HFS+ will not be changing its
> normalization algorithms to preserve backwards compatibility with existing
> volumes, that doesn't appear to be a nasty issue after all. Is there another
> issue I've failed to address in this thread?

Well, Ted answered that part, noting that then the "normalisation" is
patchy, and everyone else is left to guess what chars are normalised
and what chars aren't so being HFS+ compatible becomes a very weird
game indeed. You didn't reply to his explanation -- you called him
arrogant instead. Did you manage to read to the end if his email?

The HFS+ designers mucked it up -- and then papered over it with the
OSX libraries. But a good chunk of the world does not use them, they
forgot about the little "interop" requirement.

cheers,


m
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe git" in
the body of a message to majordomo@vger.kernel.org
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html